Why Selling Non-Operated AFE Interests Now Could Be a Smart Move — Even With Sub-$60 WTI

How Year-End Tax Planning and IDC-Driven Capital Are Creating Strong Value for Sellers

As 2025 enters the final stretch, many non-operated working interest owners face an important strategic decision: participate in newly issued AFEs and commit capital into the upcoming drilling cycle, or consider selling their non-operated wellbore interests and redeploying capital elsewhere.

At first glance, selling when WTI is trading under $60 per barrel may appear counterintuitive. Historically, sellers prefer to transact in stronger price environments when commodity momentum drives valuations higher.

However, current market dynamics—particularly driven by aggressively motivated IDC buyers—are creating an environment where sellers may receive premium value today that may not persist into early 2026. For many owners, the economics of selling now instead of funding upcoming AFEs can represent a meaningful balance-sheet and tax-efficiency upside.

---

1. The Strongest Buyer Demand Is Coming From IDC-Motivated Capital

Many well-capitalized family offices, and private investment groups are actively pursuing non-op AFE acquisitions specifically to capture Intangible Drilling Cost (IDC) deductions before year-end.

IDC write-offs offer:

• 80–100% first-year deduction against ordinary income

• Ability to shelter income from business income and other sources

• Meaningful tax-driven return uplift compared to purely economic drilling investment

This tax treatment creates premium buyer demand that is not driven strictly by well economics—meaning buyers may pay more today than traditional PV-based economic models would support.

What This Means for Sellers

Buyers who need IDC deductions before December 31st are motivated by tax requirements rather than commodity pricing. As a result:

• IDC buyers often pay premium value for AFEs relative to economic value

• Sellers can monetize today’s capital requirement at an attractive valuation

• Avoid exposure to near-term commodity price volatility

---

2. Sub-$60 WTI Means Less Competition Among Participants—and More Leverage for Sellers

Many non-op owners are reluctant to fund AFEs at today’s lower commodity strip, which causes:

• Fewer groups choosing to participate

• Higher concentration of motivated IDC buyers

• Increased pricing competition among the groups that do want to buy

Rather than writing large checks into uncertain early-cycle production, selling now lets owners:

• Reduce capital exposure

• De-risk cash flow timing

• Reinvest into proven PDP or mineral-only opportunities

When the broader market is cautious, those who act tend to capture premium value.

---

3. A Sale Today Can Replace Future Cash Flow With Immediate, Certain Liquidity

Participating in AFEs ties capital up for:

• 6–18 months prior to measurable cash flow

• Drilling and completion timeline variability

• Commodity price exposure

• Operator development risk

• Operational issues (equipment delays, DUC scheduling, basis exposure, gas takeaway)

A sale today converts uncertain future value into:

• Immediate realized returns

• Cash redeployment capability for alternative investments

• Strengthened capital position for 2026 strategy

Even in a rising price environment, the time value of money and risk-adjusted return can favor selling.

---

4. The Option Value: Selling Part or All of the AFE

Many private owners don’t realize they have flexibility:

• Sell 100% of the working interest

• Sell only the AFE / wellbore going forward, retaining PDP and/or mineral base

• Sell a partial slice to minimize exposure

Strategic structuring allows owners to:

• Reduce exposure now while maintaining upside if prices improve

• Create immediate tax events or capital repositioning opportunities

• Optimize long-term asset mix

---

5. Why Now May Be the Best Window

Several forces converging in Q4 have created a unique opportunity:
✔ Premium pricing due to tax-driven demand
✔ Compressed transaction timelines
✔ Limited participating capital in sub-$60 WTI environment
✔ Attractive market clearing prices relative to risk profile
✔ Strong buyer competition from family offices and high-income investors seeking IDC shelters

When WTI rebounds over $65–$70:

• IDC buyers may retreat

• Competition for AFEs increases

• Sellers could face tighter bid/ask spreads and lower relative premiums

---

How Eagle River Energy Advisors Can Help

Eagle River is active in AFE the space with opportunities across major U.S. basins and works directly with:

• IDC buyers

• Family offices & tax-motivated funds

• Operators needing commitment certainty

• Institutional acquisition groups

Our team brings:

• Real-time market data

• Competitive offer solicitation and execution

• Rapid closing ability—critical for year-end IDC requirements

Whether you are considering selling completely, trimming exposure, or simply evaluating options, now is an opportune time to explore value.

---

Interested in Receiving a Market Valuation or Offers?

We would welcome the opportunity to evaluate your upcoming AFEs confidentially and discuss pricing expectations based on current buyer activity.

📩 Contact
Eagle River Energy Advisors
info@eagleriverenergyadvisors.com
303-832-5128

---

Conclusion

Even with sub-$60 WTI pricing, current IDC-driven buyer demand is creating pricing levels that justify exiting or partially monetizing non-operated AFE exposure today. Selling in this window reduces risk, improves capital flexibility, and may deliver a stronger return than drilling through uncertain price cycles.

The next 30–45 days present one of the best seller windows of the year.